The two articles selected this
week, Santarelli et al. (2003) and Bessa et al. (2009), investigated neurogenesis
in the hippocampus with administration of anti-depressants (ADs) and how it
might affect the alleviation of behaviors associated with depression. Upon first
glance, the articles seem to contradict each other. But with a more thorough
read-through of the papers and an understanding that as time goes on, more discoveries
are made within the neuroscience community. Santarelli et. al seems to be a necessary
precursor to Bessa et al. in developing a deeper understanding of ADs.
In Santarelli et al., mice were
subjected to a novelty-suppressed feeding task in order to study how ADs effect
neurogenesis. This article discovered that disrupting the neurogenesis induced
by ADs through use of radiation blocked the behavioral response to the ADs. The
major finding of the paper was that the behavioral effects of ADs might be the
result of stimulation of neurogenesis in the hippocampus. Bessa et al. takes
this research in a different direction. It refutes the claim that neurogenesis
in the hippocampus is reason for the amelioration of depressive symptoms with
the use of ADs and instead takes the approach that neural plasticity is responsible
for the amelioration of depressive symptoms. Bessa et al. also performs behavioral
tasks on mice but with a more all-encompassing approach. This article uses a novelty-suppressed
feeding task, a sucrose preference task, and a forced swimming task to assess
the effects that ADs have rather than just the novelty-suppressed feeding task
from Santarelli et al. paper. The takeaway from Bessa et al. was that ADs
retain their therapeutic properties even with neurogenesis is blocked.
So although Bessa et al. rejects
the claim that neurogenesis in the hippocampus with AD use is reason from the
alleviation of behaviors associated with depression, it relies on previous
research being done in this area to get to its new conclusion that neuroplasticity
in the hippocampus with AD use is reason from the alleviation of behaviors associated
with depression.
Comments
Post a Comment