Skip to main content

Depression-Related Behaviors, Tye and Chaudhury


Both Tye et al and Chaudhury et al saw robust results from activating and inactivating the VTA in depression-related behaviors. I think their findings are both elegantly done and contribute to a bigger story of the VTA and its involvement in mediating behaviors associated with depression. Tye et al show that by inhibiting VTA neurons after Chronic Mild Stress, depressive-like behaviors are induced. By activating the same subset of neurons, escape behaviors after CMS can be restored. Additionally, Tye et al showed that activation of the VTA in rats increases the prevalence of escape behavior in a novel stress test. Chaudhury et al utilize a different stress paradigm called the social defeat stress model. Their data indicate that phasic stimulation of the VTA causes depressive-liked behaviors in a social defeat paradigm, but inhibiting the VTA can restore social interaction in mice after they experience social defeat.

 Each paper explores related, yet different concepts. Although they come to different conclusions when activating and inactivating the VTA, I think the data are still complementary. While Tye et al mainly study stress models that display escape behavior, Chaudhury et al use a stress model that studies social interaction. Both behavioral paradigms are categorized under “Chronic Mild Stress,” yet they are testing two separate aspects that are seen in depression. The overlapping behavior test between the two papers, the sucrose-preference test, examines the anhedonic phenotype under two different conditions: social stress and learned helplessness. This could explain why they see differential results.

Chaudhury et al go a step further in studying the VTA by isolating specific projection routes of the VTA. While their data give great insight into how the VTA-NAc and VTA-mPFC circuits may modulate depressive-like behavior, it’s difficult to believe their interpretation of the results. This is because (a) they only studied male mice and (b) many other known outputs of the VTA are ignored. While their paper offers promising results for interpreting the functional importance of individual VTA circuits, I am still skeptical about there being other factors that may have led to the results they saw.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Gut-brain axis

This weeks papers Reber et al. 2016 and Buffington et al. 2016 present a super interesting look into the gut-brain axis. Regarding both of these papers, it was amazing to see how potent favorable or unfavorable gut microbiome compositions are in affecting neuronal signaling and overall behavior. Reber et al. shows how immunoregulatory immunization with specifically heat killed M.vaccae can serve as a protective factor against chronic subordinate stress induce colotis as well as behavioral symptoms due to chronic stress as such. Interestringly, this paper depleted regulatory T cell activity via the anti CD25 antibody in order to show that the antiinflammatory mechanism induced by m vaccae immunization is depented on the secondary regulatory mechanisms offered by Treg proliferation and signaling. But, when T reg signaling was removed, this did not seem to cause a significant change in behavior . Therefore, this begs the consideration of what othe rmechanisms may be at play in order ...

Post 2: VTA, Dopamine, and Depression

In Tye’s 2012 paper, she utilized optogenetic stimulation of VTA dopamine neurons to study the role of said cell firing in depression. She found that inhibition of VTA DA neurons induces depression behaviors. Phasic activation of these neurons leads to symptom reversal in these mice with increased escape behaviors in tail suspension and sucrose preference. Further, she wanted to study cell firing in lasting depression-induced with a chronic mild stress paradigm. In this case, phasic activation of these cells also reversed symptoms. She wanted to see the necessity of dopamine and glutamate receptors. In the case of a glutamate agonist, struggling behaviors increased overall. Dopamine-blockade reduced struggling and is required for escape behaviors. Phasic activation of these VTA DA neurons requires functional DA receptors and the NAc neurons encode for this activation and escape behavior. Altogether, she found that VTA DA neuron firing underlies anticipating receipt o...

Observational Learning, Sial & Allsop

Vicarious stress, which Sial et al and Allsop et al studied in their experiments, is an important component of understanding psychological disorders. Since the beginning of psychology as a field, psychologists have published many different theories of emotion and learning and the mechanisms that underlie their behavioral responses. However, recreating these theories to ethically test their validity in rodents has been, and still is, a challenge. Through their observational learning tasks, Sial and Allsop show ways in which learning vicariously can elucidate the biology that underlie PTSD-like phenotypes. Sial et al propose a novel vicarious social stress paradigm in which mice can experience emotional stress rather than physical stress, as other forms of social defeat stress include. This model of emotional stress does a nice job of showing that emotional stress, although it may not be immediately apparent, has similar effects on a rodent’s corticosterone levels and...